After a senseless loss, hotheaded Caleb Hochstedler left his Amish faith and his young wife to seek justice. Two years later, he tracks his parents´ killer back home to Johns Mill, where he´s astonished to learn he´s the father of twins. Now he´s determined to protect his children and the woman he still loves - if she´ll let him. Her new husband´s abandonment broke Rhoda Lambright´s heart and proved her father, the bishop, right. Such a stubborn man could never be happy among the peaceful Amish. When Caleb unexpectedly returns, Rhoda is caught between her rock of a husband and a very hard place. Her church forbids divorce and requires forgiveness, so Rhoda lets Caleb back into their home. But can she ever let him back into her heart? One thing´s for certain sure. This second chance will take all the faith they can find.